House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., argued Friday that global inflation “starts with [Russian President Vladimir] Putin,” but that increased U.S. government spending on domestic social programs would help decrease the national debt and bring down inflation at home.”
Ms. Pelosi is a very smart woman. So she knows that what she said is complete nonsense. But, being such a smart and powerful person, she (her preferred pronoun) also knows that no one is going to dispute her. Except for the Rich Freggiaro Cycling Blog! I should probably be worried about being put on a ‘no fly list’ or being audited by the IRS.
Gas prices in the U.S. averaged $2.33 on January 6, 2021. On February 1, 2022, well before Russia invaded Ukraine, the price had risen 48% to $3.46.
Now on to the fanciful notion that increased government spending will decrease the national debt and bring down inflation at home. Really this is such an outrageous statement that I can hardly stop laughing. Except it isn’t that funny.
Here is a picture for your consideration. Discussion to follow:

The red line is the rate of inflation measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The black line is the rate of growth in the money supply as measured by M2.
The CPI is kind of self explanatory, but we need to spend a moment on M2. If you add up all the money in checking accounts, all the physical currency in circulation, and certain savings accounts and short term CD’s, you get M2. M2 is considered the best measure of the money supply.
So far so good. But things are about to get very complicated. We know the US government has the power to print money. But how much that money is worth depends on how much they print. That responsibility had been delegated to the Federal Reserve, a powerful and semi autonomous government agency. The Fed has the power, authority and tools to control how fast M2 grows.
Over time the money supply needs to grow at roughly the same rate as real GDP (Gross Domestic Product, a measure of the goods and services produced). If you are a loyal reader you will remember PQ=MV. Q is real GDP, and it grows over time. So for prices to be stable and the economy to grow, M has to grow too (V is assumed to be relatively stable).
Conspiracy lovers blame the Fed for everything from the price of gas to the common cold, or now the Common Covid. I’m not one of those at all. But what the Fed does, in cooperation with the Congress and Executive Office regarding Federal deficit spending, affects the value of money. More than Putin’s war does.
Now to the chart. Notice how sometimes the black line spikes up far above the red line? Then what happens? The black line falls and the red line rises until it close to or above the black line. The simplistic conclusion is that when M2 is allowed to grow faster that real GDP, inflation follows. When M2 growth is restrained, the rate of inflation comes down.
The chart goes back to the early 1940’s, WWII years. Back then the US Government was spending way more money that it took in in taxes, i.e. deficit spending. But prices were kept low by using price controls, and since prices were artificially low ration cards were issued to dampen demand for goods. After the war price controls were lifted and all that created M2 went around chasing goods that weren’t there. Inflation!
Same thing in the 1970’s. Deficit spending for Vietnam, social programs, the Cold War, whatever. The Fed played along by sopping up Treasury Bonds and letting M2 get ahead of itself. Inflation spiked twice soon after.
Then came a long period of relative price stability and stable money supply growth, and all was well until 2008, when some Wall Street creations called ‘derivatives’ that were supposedly rated AAA turned out to be based on inflated housing prices and were really more like FFF. There was a steep drop in M2 and everyone was worried about deflation and a collapse of the US economy resembling what happened in 1929 through 1932. The Fed reacted by quickly restoring M2 and putting ‘liquidity’ into the financial markets to avert a crisis. Deflation averted, unlike what happened in 1929, when the Fed sat on its hands and let M2 fall something like 30% and allowed banks to fail. Depression followed.
So with all that as background, look what happened in 2020 and into 2021. M2 grew faster than at any point in the past 80 years. Remember that money that magically appeared in your bank checking account? M2 growth. Free Covid tests and masks and emergency production of ventilators which proved to be unnecessary and even counterproductive? Financed by M2 growth making the deficit spending possible. Hospital ships moved into New York harbor and emergency Covid centers like the one at Arco Arena in Sacto, which never housed a single patient?. M2 again.
All this may or may not have been a good idea as a reaction to the Covid pandemic, aka Pandemia, which is a great book by Alex Berenson about events since March 2020. I’m not going to debate anyone about Covid policy. But I’m not going to let Ms. Pelosi’s comments stand without at least a little push back. Even if it does get me on a ‘no fly’ list. Mr. Putin is a bad man causing the world much trouble. But if you are upset about rising prices, look to Washington, not Moscow.















